It isn’t just businesses up and down the South West of England and beyond – including many that have reached out to TS Partners about our digital accountancy in Plymouth, Wellington, or Newton Abbot – that have been looking to modernise their approaches to tax in recent years.
That’s because, since HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) announced its Making Tax Digital (MTD) scheme in the mid-2010s, the tax office has been seeking to revamp its own systems for three business taxes – VAT, income tax self-assessment, and corporation tax.
The focus of the initiative has been on digitising records and moving bookkeeping online. However, the digital tax drive has now been the subject of criticism from the National Audit Office (NAO), which has said the programme is more than three years late and has exceeded its original budget by more than £1 billion.
What has the NAO said about the situation with Making Tax Digital?
In its report entitled “Progress with Making Tax Digital”, Parliament’s spending watchdog said that HMRC’s plan for the digital transformation of tax had failed to properly take into account the upfront costs imposed on millions of taxpayers.
The NAO report stated that the tax body had left out significant costs to customers from key business case documents that had sought approval for additional funding.
HMRC had intended to transfer its tax systems and records onto a modern tax management platform by 2020. However, the NAO said that this original deadline for getting the system up and running was “not realistic”, with it now being anticipated that the scheme will cost £1.3 billion, compared to the £226 million officials had budgeted for in 2016.
Although there have now been four delays to Making Tax Digital, the taxman has made a certain amount of progress with the initiative. Some 3.2 million tax records have been moved onto the new HMRC IT systems, but more than 14 million files are still awaiting transferral.
Since 2019, VAT has been processed with the use of tools from Making Tax Digital. Self-assessment, though, has ended up being “far more complex”, and has been subject to continued delays.
The tax office’s efforts to deliver the new system on time have also been hampered by a need to redirect resources to deal with Brexit, as well as staffing constraints during the COVID-19 crisis.
In May last year, HMRC had forecast that taxpayers would face total net ongoing costs of around £900 million over five years in order to achieve MTD compliance.
However, the tax body’s business case for the project had not accounted for the cost of obtaining tax advice, and the expense that customers would incur in updating their own systems.
Was the original aim of putting MTD in place by 2020 “never viable”?
Chairman of Parliament’s Committee of Public Accounts, Meg Hillier, said that it was “never viable” to implement Making Tax Digital for a 2020 deadline, adding: “HMRC wanted to increase tax revenue, but completely underestimated the cost and scale of work required to move from its legacy systems and by business taxpayers to move to digital records.
“Eight years on, many tax professionals remain unconvinced by the proposed approach, which imposes significant costs and burdens on many self-assessment business taxpayers… [HMRC] now needs to demonstrate its plans add up.”
A spokesman for HMRC, however, said it welcomed the watchdog’s “recognition of our progress in digitalising the tax system, and its confirmation that our plans can improve the system’s efficiency and effectiveness.”
The tax office added that MTD would “deliver a strong return on investment for the taxpayer.” It has now targeted 2027 for the implementation of its digital tax regime for self-assessment, although the review body said this still seemed to be a “very challenging plan”.
Reach out to TS Partners to learn more about our own services in digital accounting
As professionals with no shortage of expertise and experience ourselves in digital accountancy in Plymouth, Newton Abbot, and Wellington, our team at TS Partners will certainly keep a close eye on how HMRC’s tax transformation efforts continue to take shape.
In the meantime, if your own organisation requires specialised knowhow in such matters, please don’t hesitate to enquire to us to learn more about how we can help.
It isn’t just businesses up and down the South West of England and beyond – including many that have reached out to TS Partners about our digital accountancy in Plymouth, Wellington, or Newton Abbot – that have been looking to modernise their approaches to tax in recent years.
That’s because, since HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) announced its Making Tax Digital (MTD) scheme in the mid-2010s, the tax office has been seeking to revamp its own systems for three business taxes – VAT, income tax self-assessment, and corporation tax.
The focus of the initiative has been on digitising records and moving bookkeeping online. However, the digital tax drive has now been the subject of criticism from the National Audit Office (NAO), which has said the programme is more than three years late and has exceeded its original budget by more than £1 billion.
What has the NAO said about the situation with Making Tax Digital?
In its report entitled “Progress with Making Tax Digital”, Parliament’s spending watchdog said that HMRC’s plan for the digital transformation of tax had failed to properly take into account the upfront costs imposed on millions of taxpayers.
The NAO report stated that the tax body had left out significant costs to customers from key business case documents that had sought approval for additional funding.
HMRC had intended to transfer its tax systems and records onto a modern tax management platform by 2020. However, the NAO said that this original deadline for getting the system up and running was “not realistic”, with it now being anticipated that the scheme will cost £1.3 billion, compared to the £226 million officials had budgeted for in 2016.
Although there have now been four delays to Making Tax Digital, the taxman has made a certain amount of progress with the initiative. Some 3.2 million tax records have been moved onto the new HMRC IT systems, but more than 14 million files are still awaiting transferral.
Since 2019, VAT has been processed with the use of tools from Making Tax Digital. Self-assessment, though, has ended up being “far more complex”, and has been subject to continued delays.
The tax office’s efforts to deliver the new system on time have also been hampered by a need to redirect resources to deal with Brexit, as well as staffing constraints during the COVID-19 crisis.
In May last year, HMRC had forecast that taxpayers would face total net ongoing costs of around £900 million over five years in order to achieve MTD compliance.
However, the tax body’s business case for the project had not accounted for the cost of obtaining tax advice, and the expense that customers would incur in updating their own systems.
Was the original aim of putting MTD in place by 2020 “never viable”?
Chairman of Parliament’s Committee of Public Accounts, Meg Hillier, said that it was “never viable” to implement Making Tax Digital for a 2020 deadline, adding: “HMRC wanted to increase tax revenue, but completely underestimated the cost and scale of work required to move from its legacy systems and by business taxpayers to move to digital records.
“Eight years on, many tax professionals remain unconvinced by the proposed approach, which imposes significant costs and burdens on many self-assessment business taxpayers… [HMRC] now needs to demonstrate its plans add up.”
A spokesman for HMRC, however, said it welcomed the watchdog’s “recognition of our progress in digitalising the tax system, and its confirmation that our plans can improve the system’s efficiency and effectiveness.”
The tax office added that MTD would “deliver a strong return on investment for the taxpayer.” It has now targeted 2027 for the implementation of its digital tax regime for self-assessment, although the review body said this still seemed to be a “very challenging plan”.
Reach out to TS Partners to learn more about our own services in digital accounting
As professionals with no shortage of expertise and experience ourselves in digital accountancy in Plymouth, Newton Abbot, and Wellington, our team at TS Partners will certainly keep a close eye on how HMRC’s tax transformation efforts continue to take shape.
In the meantime, if your own organisation requires specialised knowhow in such matters, please don’t hesitate to enquire to us to learn more about how we can help.
Latest Posts

- 22
- Nov
In recent years, we’ve witnessed a significant shift among company car drivers, especially directors of owner-managed businesses, towards Electric Vehicles (EVs) to capitalize on the available t…

- 13
- Oct
What is Land Remediation Tax Relief? If your property is owned or leased by a limited company, you (whether landlord or tenant) may be able to get tax relief on the costs of removing the asbestos and …

- 13
- Oct
Navigating the UK business terrain, it’s clear that the right funding can pivot your growth trajectory. With this in mind, TS Partners has teamed up with Swoop, creating a bridge between your f…

- 13
- Oct
Despite the limited tax breaks for UK commercial property owners or investors, many overlook the significant tax relief provided by capital allowances. This oversight often arises from unfamiliarity w…

- 12
- Sep
For a while now, there have been persistent suggestions that the UK could be on the verge of entering a recession – and according to at least one authoritative source, that moment may finally come l…

- 8
- Sep
Following an extended period of time in which the outlook did not seem greatly positive for very many businesses in the UK, our experts at TS Partners were cheered to read that according to one new bu…

- 6
- Sep
Talk of recession risk for the UK is becoming a very well-worn theme at this point, but it is also sadly true that many an accountant in Newton Abbot – and their clients – must bear such a risk in…

- 17
- Aug
As things stood at the time of this article being written, the destination of the Women’s World Cup trophy was yet to be decided; nonetheless, the England team has already captured the imaginations …

- 4
- Aug
Firms around the South West of England – including many taking advantage of TS Partners’ expertise in accounting in Newton Abbot – seem to be remaining confident as the summer of 2023 wears on, …

- 28
- Jul
Recent months, it is fair to say, have been ones of ups and downs for many UK business owners, who have been anxious to see reasons for optimism. The UK did at least avoid what had once been a widely …

- 21
- Jul
It has been clear for all to see in recent times that firms across the UK have been buffeted by a range of adverse factors, not least inflation and climbing interest rates. However, at least one recen…

- 17
- Jul
There sadly isn’t a lack of indicators of the exceedingly challenging situation for many small businesses in the UK – and beyond – at the moment. Sure enough, another one has emerged, with it be…

- 12
- Jul
According to at least one source, it would seem that confidence in the UK economy among the country’s business leaders has declined markedly recently, erasing the progress that had been made in this…

- 10
- Jul
In news that will not be cheering for the Bank of England (BoE) as it continues to struggle to drive down inflation, it has emerged that a far greater number of companies in the UK services sector are…

- 2
- Jul
Amid continuing concerns about inflation and the economy, it seems that the UK Government has at least some reason for cheer: the “tax gap” for the year 2021 to 2022 has remained at its lowest eve…

- 28
- Jun
In a development that has been described by one industry expert as “somewhat ironic”, it has emerged that the non-departmental funding body UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) owes HM Revenue & …

- 26
- Jun
UK organisations that are keen to take responsible and compliant approaches to their tax and accounting in Newton Abbot, Plymouth, or Wellington may be interested to read about new Government plans th…

- 24
- Jun
No doubt that for many of our blog readers, the various business surveys, indexes, and barometers will be key topics of reading and conversation, as business owners around the UK assess the prospects …